Arizona insiders warn GOP, Dems to learn from midterms
National News
Audio By Carbonatix
2:34 PM on Tuesday, November 17
(The Center Square) – Two of the most connected insiders in Arizona politics warned both Republicans and Democrats to learn from this year’s midterms.
Joe Wolf, founder of Fillmore Partners, and Laddie Shane, founder and president of Roosevelt Strategy Group, discussed their takeaways from the Nov. 3 election at Tuesday morning’s “Coffee & Common Sense” event. The Common Sense Institute of Arizona presented the program at the Flinn Foundation in Phoenix.
At the one-hour panel, Wolf, who has worked around Democratic politics for years, including as Gov. Katie Hobbs’ senior campaign adviser in 2022, said the blue wave doesn’t mean that the Grand Canyon State has shifted politically.
Instead, Wolf argued Democrats’ ability to earn their first trifecta in 60 years was more the result of voters' anger at the Republican Party ignoring them.
“To me, this has always been a story of very educated voters making a business decision on what is good for their families, what is good for the state, and deciding that we don't want to be associated with these far-right wing, out-of-touch Republican candidates,” Wolf said.
“So I wouldn't even call us a purple state. I think we are a center right state, a Republican state, where the majority of voters want moderate, conservative, center-right candidates,” he added.
Who gets the blame?
Shane, who worked for two Republicans, former Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich and former Gov. Doug Ducey, told the crowd that the GOP needs to find a new guiding ethos in the post-Donald Trump era, both in Arizona and beyond.
“Donald Trump should get the blame. This is Donald Trump's mess. This is where it all begins,” Shane said. “A war that never ends that’s entirely discretionary that has led to incredibly high gas prices, tariffs that have led to everything under the sun becoming more expensive, just meddling in the market. This is this is all on Trump. The Republican Party is going to suffer immensely the longer they continue to let him dominate Republican politics.”
Shane said he’s hopeful the GOP will learn from this year’s rout at the ballot box, saying he believes the party’s hit what he termed “pitch black,” leaving them ample room to rebuild the party and move forward.
Wolf, meanwhile, praised this year’s crop of legislative and statewide Democratic candidates in Arizona for sticking with the message surrounding affordability in Arizona.
The question now, in Shane’s opinion, is whether the Democrats can govern as well as they campaigned, saying it’s one thing to do the former but an entirely different task to succeed with the latter.
“I do think it will be interesting to see, do we all get on the rowboat, or will we see some of that fractioning internally,” Shane said. “Winning is actually the easy part. Governing is much, much harder.”
Pulling the purse strings
Another topic that Wolf is keeping an eye on as Arizona approaches the opening day of the 58th Legislature on Jan. 11 is whether the Democrats will use their newfound legislative power to push through a number of policy goals that’ll carry lofty price tags, or if they’ll opt to be more measured in their spending commitments. Democrats will have control of both houses.
“Now that they’re in the driver’s seat, they’ll want to spend some money,” Wolf said. “Republicans have been able to do now for 60-plus years, and (Democrats) just get a tiny slice of the piece, a little handout here and there, and coax a few extra votes to make the budget go down smoothly.
“So they’re going to have priorities. Individual members are going to want to do things for their district," he added. "They’re going to have pet projects that they’re going to want to get funded, and we just don’t have that much revenue to go around."
Wolf said it’ll all be fun and games for the Democrats until Gov. Hobbs releases her executive budget next year. He sees that as the reflection point for the party, where real in-fighting will begin and party leadership will be tested.
One such friction point could be whether legislative Democrats whip up enough votes to call for a special election on Proposition 123, which was passed by voters in 2016 to up the State Land Trust Permanent Fund contribution to K-12 schools from 2.5% to 6.9%.
Lawmakers let the proposition expire in 2025, meaning legislators will have to call for a special election to get it reinstated.
“How effectively they are able to resolve that to me will be the story of this session,” Wolf said. “There’s stuff they can find common ground on, but at the end of the day, money is going to dominate from every disagreement they have.”
Looking forward
When asked who the real winner was in this year’s slew of statewide and legislative Democratic Party victories, both Wolf and Shane spotlighted Attorney General Kris Mayes, a Democrat who defeated Senate President Warren Petersen, R-Gilbert, by 11%.
“I think she this put her in the driver's seat for the Democratic nomination for governor of 2030,” Wolf said of Mayes. “I think that her performance and the way she ran her campaign and the way she's kind of been focusing her office, at least outwardly, in service of building that brand on holding abusers accountable.
“Whether it's people stealing our water or inflating our housing crisis, she's doing a good job of messaging in a way that people want to hear right now,” he added.
Shane said he’s interested in seeing how the state’s GOP leadership gets off the mat, looking at how to lead the party forward and answer the message that voters sent earlier this month.
The longtime GOP insider said there’s a chance for the party to start anew in 2027 if it takes the right lessons away from this year’s losses, forging a new path that veers away from the president and answers the call of the state’s voters.
“I think for Republicans, we are in an interesting place to decide how that pendulum swings more than ever,” Shane said. “And I think it is up to people in this room, everybody, to decide what that swing is going to look like.”